Planning a bathroom remodel in West Covina and stuck on the big question: shower or tub? You’re not alone. Choosing between these two features is one of the most debated decisions in bathroom design. It affects everything from daily comfort and long-term home value to layout, budget, and resale appeal.
This guide dives into the pros and cons of both options, helping you weigh the factors that matter most. If you’re exploring bathroom remodeling choices in West Covina, this article will walk you through the details that can lead to a confident, practical decision.
Understand Your Lifestyle and Daily Routine
The first step in deciding between a shower or tub is understanding how you and your household use the bathroom. Your routine plays a major role in shaping the most functional and satisfying choice.
Questions to ask:
- Do you prefer quick, energizing showers or relaxing soaks?
- Do you have children who need a tub?
- Is accessibility a concern for older adults or anyone with mobility issues?
Many West Covina homeowners opt for showers for speed and accessibility, while others maintain at least one tub in the home for relaxation or resale considerations.
The Pros and Cons of Installing a Shower
Showers are a popular choice in modern bathroom renovations for their sleek design and space efficiency. They also support aging-in-place goals and water conservation.
Pros:
- Saves space in small bathrooms
- Easier to access for seniors or those with disabilities
- Uses less water compared to full tubs
- Allows for modern touches like rainfall showerheads or frameless glass enclosures
Cons:
- Not ideal for families with young children
- May impact resale appeal if it’s the only bathing option in the home
Showers are especially appealing in compact homes or condos throughout West Covina where space is limited and modern aesthetics are preferred. Explore more design tips on our bathroom remodeling blog.
The Pros and Cons of Installing a Bathtub
Tubs offer a different kind of comfort. They’re ideal for soaking, bathing kids, and creating a spa-like retreat within your own home.
Pros:
- Great for families with small children
- Offers therapeutic soaking
- Adds to luxury appeal in master bathrooms
- May increase home value in family-friendly neighborhoods
Cons:
- Takes up more floor space
- Requires more water per use
- Can be difficult for those with limited mobility
Many West Covina homeowners include tubs in master bathrooms or guest baths where space and accessibility aren’t issues. A good rule of thumb: if your home has more than one bathroom, having at least one tub is often a smart choice.
Consider Bathroom Size and Layout
Your bathroom’s size and existing plumbing layout can heavily influence whether a shower or tub makes sense. Fitting a large soaking tub into a small room may require more extensive renovations and costs.
Tips:
- A walk-in shower can fit into a smaller footprint than a tub
- Converting a tub to a shower is often easier than the reverse
- Measure floor area and wall clearance before deciding
- Consider vertical space for showerheads or shelving
If you’re unsure how to optimize your space, consulting a bathroom remodel expert in West Covina can help you make the most of your square footage.
Think About Long-Term Home Value
When considering resale, both showers and tubs offer benefits. However, the choice can influence how your home appeals to future buyers.
Market insights:
- A home with at least one bathtub tends to appeal more to families with children
- Walk-in showers are attractive to older buyers and couples
- Master bathrooms with spa-like tubs can increase property value
If your home has only one full bathroom, keeping a tub is often advisable. But if you already have a tub elsewhere in the house, converting one to a walk-in shower could boost functionality and modern appeal. Learn more about smart home remodeling choices in West Covina by reviewing local trends.
Budget Considerations for Showers vs. Tubs
Cost is always a factor in any remodel. While prices can vary greatly, there are some general guidelines when comparing a tub to a walk-in shower.
Cost comparison:
- Standard tub installation: $800 to $3,000
- Soaking or jetted tub: $1,500 to $7,000+
- Shower conversion or new build: $2,000 to $8,000 depending on tile, plumbing, and enclosure materials
Tubs are typically less expensive if you go with a standard model. However, luxury tubs or full conversions can raise the price. Walk-in showers often require custom tile work, which can add to your total budget.
For more on keeping costs low while remodeling, visit our article on affordable bathroom upgrades.
Combining Both: The Best of Both Worlds
Can’t decide? Why not do both? Many homeowners in West Covina are combining a shower and tub in the same remodel, especially in master bathrooms.
Common combo options:
- Tub and separate walk-in shower (requires more space)
- Shower-tub combo with glass partition
- Freestanding tub beside a tiled walk-in enclosure
This option allows for flexibility, supports all household members, and enhances resale appeal by checking both boxes.
Conclusion
Choosing between a shower or tub is not just a matter of preference. It’s about functionality, design, long-term value, and how the space fits your needs now and in the future. Whether you’re creating a spa-like retreat or a practical everyday bath, the right choice will align with your lifestyle and your home’s layout.
Still unsure which option is right for your remodel? Serenity Home Remodeling can guide you through every step, from layout decisions to material selection. Our team brings extensive experience to bathroom remodels across West Covina. Visit our about page to learn more, or contact us here to schedule a consultation. For more remodeling ideas and expert tips, check out our blog.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
1. Is it okay to remove the only bathtub in my home?
It depends on your household and future plans. If you intend to sell soon, buyers may expect at least one tub in the home.
2. Which is easier to maintain, a shower or tub?
Showers with frameless glass are easier to clean. Tubs may require more attention, especially jetted models.
3. Can I convert my bathtub into a walk-in shower?
Yes, this is a common remodel. Make sure to assess plumbing, tile work, and accessibility.
4. What adds more value to a home, a tub or a shower?
Value depends on your local market. In West Covina, family homes often benefit from at least one tub, while walk-in showers appeal to aging buyers.
5. Are walk-in showers safe for older adults?
Yes. Consider adding grab bars, a bench, and non-slip tiles for added safety.
6. Do freestanding tubs take up more space?
They typically require more room around them compared to built-in tubs, so they’re best in larger bathrooms.
7. What’s trending in bathroom remodeling in 2025?
Black fixtures, natural textures, rain showers, and floating vanities are top trends.
8. How do I make a shower feel luxurious?
Use custom tile designs, niche storage, rainfall showerheads, and frameless glass panels.
9. What’s the best layout for small bathrooms?
Walk-in corner showers and wall-mounted vanities help open up space.
10. How do I decide which option fits my remodel goals?
Start with your lifestyle, household needs, budget, and long-term plans. Consulting a remodeler can also help.
